Development of an online measurement method for radioactive gases based on porous scintillators
As the national metrology laboratory for ionizing radiation, the Henri Becquerel National Laboratory (LNE-LNHB) of the French Alternative Energies and Atomic Energy Commission (CEA) operates unique facilities dedicated to radionuclide metrology. These include various setups for producing liquid-phase standards, as well as systems for mixing radioactive gases. In previous research projects, a specific installation was developed for the generation of radioactive gas atmospheres [1], with the aim of creating new testing and calibration methods that meet the needs of both research and industry.
One of the major current challenges is to reproduce environmental conditions as realistically as possible in order to better address actual regulatory requirements—particularly regarding volumetric activity and measurement conditions. This general issue applies to all radioactive substances, but is especially critical for volatile radioactive substances. Over the past several years, through numerous projects and collaborations, CEA/LNHB has been exploring new detection methods that outperform traditional liquid scintillation techniques. Among these innovations are new porous inorganic scintillators [1], which enable not only online detection but also online separation (“unmixing”) of pure beta-emitting radionuclides—this technique has been patented [2].
The objective of this PhD project is to develop, implement, and optimize these measurement methods through applications to:
- Pure radioactive gases,
- Multicomponent mixtures of pure beta-emitting radioactive gases—using porous scintillators for unmixing and identification,
- Liquid scintillation counting, more generally, where this unmixing capability has recently been demonstrated at LNHB and is currently being prepared for publication.
The unmixing technique is of particular interest, as it significantly simplifies environmental monitoring by scintillation, especially in the case of ³H and ¹4C mixtures. Currently, such analyses require multiple bubbler samplings, mixing with scintillation cocktail, and triple-label methods—procedures that involve several months of calibration preparation and weeks of experimentation and processing.
This PhD will be closely aligned with a second doctoral project on Compton-TDCR [1] (2025–2028), aimed at determining the response curve of the scintillators.
The scientific challenges of the project are tied to radionuclide metrology and combine experimentation, instrumentation, and data analysis to develop innovative measurement techniques. Key objectives include:
- Developing a method for beta-emitter unmixing in scintillation, based on initial published and patented concepts.
- Assessing the precision of the unmixing method, including associated uncertainties and decision thresholds.
- Validating the unmixing technique using the laboratory’s radioactive gas test bench [1], with various radionuclides such as 3H, 14C, 133Xe, 85Kr, 222Rn,... or via conventional liquid scintillation counting.
- Enhancing the unmixing model, potentially through the use of machine learning or artificial intelligence tools, particularly for complex multicomponent mixtures.
New experimental constraints on the weak interaction coupling constants by coincidence measurements of complex decay schemes
Accurate experimental knowledge of forbidden non-unique beta transitions, which constitute about one third of all known beta transitions, is an important and very difficult subject. Only a few reliable studies exist in the literature. Indeed, the continuous energy spectrum of these transitions is difficult to measure precisely for various reasons that cumulate: high diffusivity of electrons in matter and non-linearity of the detection system, unavailability of some radionuclides and presence of impurities, long half-lives and complex decay schemes, etc. Accurate theoretical predictions are equally difficult because of the necessity of coupling different models for the atomic, the nuclear and the weak interaction parts in the same, full-relativistic formalism. However, improving our knowledge of forbidden non-unique beta transitions is essential in radioactivity metrology to define the becquerel SI unit in the case of pure beta emitters. This can have a strong impact in nuclear medicine, for the nuclear industry, and for some studies in fundamental physics such as dark matter detection and neutrino physics.
Our recent study, both theoretical and experimental, of the second forbidden non-unique transition in 99Tc decay has highlighted that forbidden non-unique transitions can be particularly sensitive to the effective values of the weak interaction coupling constants. The latter act as multiplicative factors of the nuclear matrix elements. The use of effective values compensates for the approximations used in the nuclear structure models, such as simplified correlations between the nucleons in the valence space, or the absence of core excitation. However, they can only be adjusted by comparing with a high-precision experimental spectrum. The predictability of the theoretical calculations, even the most precise currently available, is thus strongly questioned. While it has already been demonstrated that universal values cannot be fixed, effective values for each type of transition, or for a specific nuclear model, are possible. The aim of this thesis is therefore to establish new experimental constraints on the weak interaction coupling constants by precisely measuring the energy spectra of beta transitions. Ultimately, establishing robust average effective values of these coupling constants will be possible, and a real predictive power for theoretical calculations of beta decay will be obtained.
Most of the transitions of interest for constraining the coupling constants have energies greater than 1 MeV, occur in complex decay schemes and are associated to the emission of multiple gamma photons. In this situation, the best strategy consists in beta-gamma detection in coincidence. The usual detection techniques in nuclear physics are appropriate but they must be extremely well implemented and controlled. The doctoral student will rely on the results obtained in two previous theses. To minimize self-absorption of the electrons in the source, they will have to adapt a preparation technique of ultra-thin radioactive sources developed at LNHB to the important activities that will be required. He will have to implement a new apparatus, in a dedicated vacuum chamber, including a coincidence detection of two silicon detectors and two gamma detectors. Several studies will be necessary, mechanical and by Monte Carlo simulation, to optimize the geometric configuration with regard to the different constraints. The optimization of the electronics, acquisition, signal processing, data analysis, spectral deconvolution and the development of a complete and robust uncertainty budget will all be topics covered. These instrumental developments will make possible the measurement with great precision of the spectra from 36Cl, 59Fe, 87Rb, 141Ce, or 170Tm decays. This very comprehensive subject will allow the doctoral student to acquire instrumental and analytical skills that will open up many career opportunities. The candidate should have good knowledge of nuclear instrumentation, programming and Monte Carlo simulations, as well as a reasonable knowledge of nuclear disintegrations.
Development of ultra-high-resolution magnetic microcalorimeters for isotopic analysis of actinides by X-ray and gamma-ray spectrometry
The PhD project focuses on the development of ultra-high-resolution magnetic microcalorimeters (MMCs) to improve the isotopic analysis of actinides (uranium, plutonium) by X- and gamma-ray spectrometry around 100 keV. This type of analysis, which is essential for the nuclear fuel cycle and non-proliferation efforts, traditionally relies on HPGe detectors, whose limited energy resolution constrains measurement accuracy. To overcome these limitations, the project aims to employ cryogenic MMC detectors operating at temperatures below 100 mK, capable of achieving energy resolutions ten times better than that of HPGe detectors. The MMCs will be microfabricated at CNRS/C2N using superconducting and paramagnetic microstructures, and subsequently tested at LNHB. Once calibrated, they will be used to precisely measure the photon spectra of actinides in order to determine the fundamental atomic and nuclear parameters of the isotopes under study with high accuracy. The resulting data will enhance the nuclear and atomic databases used in deconvolution codes, thereby enabling more reliable and precise isotopic analysis of actinides.
architecture for embedded system of Automated and Reliable Mapping of indoor installations
The research focuses on the 3D localization of data from measurements inside buildings, where satellite location systems, such as GPS, are not operational. Different solutions exist in the literature, they rely in particular on the use of SLAM (Simultaneous Localization And Mapping) algorithms, but the 3D reconstruction is generally carried out a posteriori. In order to be able to propose this type of approach for embedded systems, a first thesis was carried out and led to a choice of algorithms to embed and a draft of the electronic architecture. A first proof of concept was also realized. Continuing this work, the thesis will have to propose a method allowing the localization device to be easily embedded on a wide range of nuclear measuring equipment (diameter, contamination meter, portable spectrometry, etc.). The work is not limited to a simple integration phase; it requires an architectural exploration, which will be based on adequacy between algorithm and architecture. These approaches will make it possible to respect different criteria, such as weight and small size so as not to compromise ergonomics for the operators carrying out the maps and quality of the reconstruction to ensure the reliability of the input data for the Digital Twin models.
Development of a transportable and high sensibility gamma/neutron spectro-imager to reconstruct and identify radioactive hotspots during decomissioning and dismantling operations
Radioactive hotspots reconstruction is a significant challenge when characterising radioelements in environments that have been impacted by radiological or nuclear activity. A thesis proposal aims to address this issue by developing a compact, highly sensitive multimodal instrument for assessing and characterising gamma-ray and neutron contributions. This system will help to meet the encountered challenges, during decommissioning and dismantling (D&D) operations, in nuclear industry sites. To do this, it will incorporate spectro-imaging specifications to ensure the identification and location of present radioelements. The state of art has already demonstrated the advantages and benefits of combining ionising radiations spectrometry and imaging. However, the suggested solutions show difficulties in deploying measurement systems (size, weight), as well as a sensitivity incompatible with the ground constraints. Results obtained in the frame of thesis works, carried out at SIMRI (Service Instrumentation et Métrologie des Rayonnements Ionisants), have led to the development of a gamma and neutron spectro-imager prototype.
Development of the Compton-TDCR Method for Scintillator Metrology
The objectives of this PhD thesis lie upstream of the applied domain, specifically in the field of radionuclide metrology. The research aims to obtain essential information for a deeper understanding of scintillation mechanisms. This topic represents a new discipline within the national metrology laboratory, currently nonexistent in other laboratories, and focuses specifically on scintillator metrology. The work will be centered on instrumentation and data analysis, enabling a refined understanding of the underlying physical phenomena. The PhD will be co-supervised by Benoit Sabot (expert in radioactivity metrology) and Christophe Dujardin (expert in scintillation).
One of the primary experimental objectives of this PhD is the development and implementation of the new Compton-TDCR setup [7], designed for the absolute measurement of scintillation yield as a function of electron energy. This system will be designed using 3D printing technology and will integrate high-purity germanium (GeHP) detectors to enhance measurement precision. After characterizing these detectors in terms of energy resolution and efficiency, they will be integrated into the final experimental setup. The PhD candidate will be responsible for signal processing using a digital module generating List-Mode files. The data will then be analyzed using an existing Rust-based software with a Python interface, which is currently limited to four channels. Given that the new setup will incorporate up to three GeHP detectors in addition to three photomultiplier channels, the software must be adapted to ensure optimal processing of the acquired data. Following fine-tuning of the electronics and a series of experimental tests, the required software modifications will be implemented to enable full data exploitation from the platform.
Once this initial phase is completed and the platform is fully operational, the candidate will focus on investigating scintillation phenomena. The first studies will examine standard scintillating materials, such as organic (liquid or plastic) and inorganic scintillators. Subsequently, the research will extend to less explored materials, such as porous scintillators. This phase will involve close collaboration with the University of Lyon, particularly with the Institut Lumière Matière, where complementary measurements will be performed to refine the analysis of scintillation phenomena, complete the laboratory findings, and develop simulations that integrate various experimental approaches.
The ultimate goal of this setup is to establish a metrology methodology for scintillators, enabling access to the response curve of these materials as a function of the energy of electrons interacting within them, as well as their temporal properties. This work will pave the way for new ionizing radiation measurement techniques and will make a significant contribution to the scientific community in this field.
Towards a multimodal photon irradiation platform: foundations and conceptualization
Photonic irradiation techniques exploit the interactions between a beam of high-energy photons and matter to carry out non-destructive measurements. By inducing photonuclear reactions such as photonic activation, nuclear resonance fluorescence (NRF) and photofission, these irradiation techniques enable deep probing of matter. Combining these different nuclear measurement techniques within a single irradiation platform would enable precise, quantitative identification of a wide variety of elements, probing the volume of the materials or objects under study. The high-energy photon beam is generally produced by the Bremsstrahlung phenomenon within a conversion target of a linear electron accelerator. An innovative alternative is to exploit the high-energy electrons delivered by a laser-plasma source, converted by Bremsstrahlung radiation or inverse Compton scattering. A platform based on such a source would open up new possibilities, as laser-plasma sources can reach significantly higher energies, enabling access to new advanced imaging techniques and applications. The aim of this thesis is to establish the foundations and conceptualize a multimodal photonic irradiation platform. Such a device would aim to be based on a laser-plasma source and would enable the combination of photonic activation, nuclear resonance fluorescence (NRF) and photofission techniques. By pushing back the limits of non-destructive nuclear measurements, this platform would offer innovative solutions to major challenges in strategic sectors such as security and border control, radioactive waste package management, and the recycling industry.
Caliste-3D CZT: development of a miniature, monolithic and hybrid gamma-ray imaging spectrometer with improved efficiency in the 100 keV to 1 MeV range and optimised for detection of the Compton effect and sub-pixel localisation
Multi-wavelength observation of astrophysical sources is the key to a global understanding of the physical processes involved. Due to instrumental constraints, the spectral band from 0.1 to 1 MeV is the one that suffers most from insufficient detection sensitivity in existing observatories. This band allows us to observe the deepest and most distant active galactic nuclei, to better understand the formation and evolution of galaxies on cosmological scales. It reveals the processes of nucleosynthesis of the heavy elements in our Universe and the origin of the cosmic rays that are omnipresent in the Universe. The intrinsic difficulty of detection in this spectral range lies in the absorption of these very energetic photons after multiple interactions in the material. This requires good detection efficiency, but also good localisation of all the interactions in order to deduce the direction and energy of the incident photon. These detection challenges are the same for other applications with a strong societal and environmental impact, such as the dismantling of nuclear facilities, air quality monitoring and radiotherapy dosimetry.
The aim of this instrumentation thesis is to develop a versatile '3D' detector that can be used in the fields of astrophysics and nuclear physics, with improved detection efficiency in the 100 keV to 1 MeV range and Compton events, as well as the possibility of locating interactions in the detector at better than pixel size.
Several groups around the world, including our own, have developed hard X-ray imaging spectrometers based on high-density pixelated semiconductors for astrophysics (CZT for NuSTAR, CdTe for Solar Orbiter and Hitomi), for synchrotron (Hexitec UK, RAL) or for industrial applications (Timepix, ADVACAM). However, their energy range remains limited to around 200 keV (except for Timepix) due to the thinness of the crystals and their intrinsic operating limitations. To extend the energy range beyond MeV, thicker crystals with good charge carrier transport properties are needed. This is currently possible with CZT, but several challenges need to be overcome.
The first challenge was the ability of manufacturers to produce thick homogeneous CZT crystals. Advances in this field over the last 20 years mean that we can now foresee detectors up to at least 10 mm thick (Redlen, Kromek).
The main remaining technical challenge is the precise estimation of the charge generated by the interaction of a photon in the semiconductor. In a pixelated detector where only the X and Y coordinates of the interaction are recorded, increasing the thickness of the crystal degrades spectral performance. Obtaining Z interaction depth information in a monolithic crystal theoretically makes it possible overcome the associated challenge. This requires the deployment of experimental methods, physical simulations, the design of readout microelectronics circuits and original data analysis methods. In addition, the ability to localise interactions in the detector to better than the size of a pixel will help to solve this challenge.